Skip to main content

The Dichotomy of Two Cultures





(clip art of education)
Snow’s idea of two cultures in education (Sciences vs. Arts) was not a new notion for me. My initial standpoint on the dichotomy of the two was a stereotypical one. Coming from South Korea, I shared the belief that many nations (such as S.K or India) still hold that traditional (phyiscal/natural) sciences is uninteresting, yet imperative to success and arts (theological/metaphysical) is fascinating, yet unnecessary. Professor Vesna articulated that this type of perception leads to problems, as cultures’ uncooperative approaches concerning the other causes lack of communication and innovation in both fields. She adds that bridging them together to create “something else”, referred to as the third culture, may be the key. 

(Image of Thinking Minds)

Living in Great Britain during a time where sciences was undervalued in relation to the humanities, Snow articulated that Sciences is the dominant field of study. However, people like Damodharan argued that the arts help a person think in ways that would not be possible through other disciplines. Sculptor Magdalena Abakanowicz also adds her own outlook on the dichotomy. 
"Art does not solve problems, but makes us aware of their existence.” 
       (Cooperation Symbol Clip Art)
Concerning my focus of study, business, I believe that the world simply does not revolve around one or the other, hence making it impossible to claim which is better. For example, success in business is something that requires more than just creative thinking or application of formulas and principles. It requires a good mix of both, which can also be classified as the “third culture”. My experience talking to various business professionals about this topic contributes to my belief in the fundamentality of the third culture, as most have claimed that the arts is imperative, and even foundational, to success.

This lesson has allowed me to recognize the dangers of stereotyping the two cultures and their dichotomy enforced by society and its leaders. Snow’s perception of the two cultures being mutually exclusive should be a notion of the past. For the betterment of any individual and society, especially in terms of education, it is crucial that we utilize and integrate both cultures in order to adequately understand world, rather than trying to critically decipher which pursuit is of greater importance.

Sources/Links
- www.huffingtonpost.in/dipin-damodharan/will-arts-make-you-smarte_b_9169536.html
- www.edutopia.org/arts-music-curriculum-child-development.
- A Portrait of the Visual Arts Meeting the Challenges of a New Era by K.F. McCarthy
- links.jstor.org/sici?sici=0024-094X%282001%2934%3A2%3C121%3ATATCBI%3E2.0.CO%3B2-3.
- “Two Cultures and the Scientific Revolution” by C.P. Snow

Bibliography

California Humanities. “Image of Thinking Minds.” Calhum, 17 Jan. 2018, calhum.org/upcoming-webinars-humanities-for-all-project-grants-quick-grants-now-open-for-applications/.
Damodharan, Dipin. “Why The Arts Are As Important As Science Or Math.” HuffPost India, HuffPost India, 15 July 2016, www.huffingtonpost.in/dipin-damodharan/will-arts-make-you-smarte_b_9169536.html.
Gatson Training. “Clip Art of Education.” InsuranceLicenseNow, 31 May 2017, insurancelicensenow.com/7-reasons-use-gatson-training-education/.
McCarthy, K.F. A Portrait of the Visual Arts Meeting the Challenges of a New Era. RAND, 2005.
OCAL. “Cooperation Symbol Clip Art.” Clcker, 13 Feb. 2011, www.clker.com/clipart-cooperation-symbol.html.
Smith, Fran. “Why Arts Education Is Crucial, and Who's Doing It Best.” Edutopia, George Lucas Educational Foundation, 28 Jan. 2009, www.edutopia.org/arts-music-curriculum-child-development.
Snow, C. P. “Two Cultures and the Scientific Revolution.” Reading. 1959. New York: Cambridge UP, 1961. Print.
Vesna, Victoria. “Toward a Third Culture: Being in Between.” JSTOR, MIT Press, 1 Jan. 2001, links.jstor.org/sici?sici=0024-094X%282001%2934%3A2%3C121%3ATATCBI%3E2.0.CO%3B2-3.


Comments

  1. Cheata SeApril 10, 2018 at 10:10 PM

    I agree that the third culture should be a mix of both arts and science. However, I do not believe that they have to be equally weighted. One can outweigh another as long as the third culture does its function -- bridging the gap between the art and science.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Jung Hoon ParkApril 11, 2018 at 9:11 PM

    I also agree that CP Snow's first idea of two cultures: art vs. science was not a new notion for me. Just as degrees in general, there are Bachelors of Arts or Bachelors of Science. Also in the campus, south side of the campus is about science, engineering, and labs in general, but north side of the campus is about history, art, and literature.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Guillermo Soria April 13, 2018 at 2:33 PM

    I like how you mentioned cultural perception of both science and art because different cultures put different values into both of these categories. For the most part, I feel like science is valued more by most cultures due to the possibility of financial gain. However, arts are mostly consumed on a day to day basis by most cultures however they are not as valued since their presence has been normalized by society.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Event 4 (Extra Credit)

Event 4 - Weak or No Signal Technology’s Impact   Technology and art are intertwined in the sense that technology has allowed for artists to expand their creativity in their work. That is, technology has become utilized as new tools for artistic expression (Gever). Art before the technological boom was predominantly shaped by people of power such as famous artists, art gallery owners, or art promoters (Gever). But now, technology has allowed for artists to be socially connected. That is, before technology was widely utilized in art, artists had to go to galleries to get their work recognized. If their work was not good enough according to the gallery’s standards, then your art would not be exposed (Gever).   Art and Technology (McCaslin) Technology in Art When did this trend of using technology for art begin? The answer is unclear as artists have been using technology to express themselves for a very long time (Rieland). However, it was mostly in the recent
Post a Comment
Read more

Event 3 Blog Post: "The Science and Art of Sound"

Event 3: Art, Science, Technology and Sound Hamdan's Sound Waves (Hammer Museum) The event I attended was an exhibition at Hammer Museum that showed the works of the artist Lawrence Abu Hamdan. According to Hammer Museum, Hamdan began this project in 2016. His project was an “acoustic investigation” of a military prison in Syria. This prison was unlike any ordinary prison, as it was known to be inaccessible to monitors and observers due to its conditions of leaving most detainees in complete darkness. Thus, Hamdan initiated his “ear witness” interviews to try to rebuild the conditions of the prison simply through the acoustic (sound) memories of the notorious prison’s former detainees. Hamdan incorporated sound-wave mapping technology to measure the sounds, ultimately reconstructing the sounds and acoustic leakage into visual form. Hammer Museum described his work as a way in which “sound becomes sight and sight becomes sound” (Hammer Museum).   Syrian Prison (Amnest
Post a Comment
Read more

Event 1 Blog: Fowler Out Loud

Science, Technology, and Music:              How Are They Related? Image of Music and Science I attended this event with the assumption that I would learn, through the contents and theme of the concert, how arts and sciences are intertwined. Contrary to my assumption, I experienced, rather than bluntly learn about, the amalgamation of music (arts) and science that is prevalent around us. More specifically, I was able to witness how the arts and sciences are intertwined, especially through the use of technology, as Professor Vesna taught in Unit 1.   The event was a simple concert featuring Jungle Rhythm, a local band that performed various hip-hop songs about a wide variety of topics including politics, comedy, and love. Although the performance was very pleasurable, the content of the performance had little to do with what we’ve learned so far in this course. However, the bigger picture concerning the overarching concept of music was what I could relate to the materi
Post a Comment
Read more